TENS is a non-invasive, safe
nerve stimulation intended to reduce pain,
both acute and chronic. While controversy
exists as to its effectiveness in the
treatment of chronic pain, a number of
systematic reviews or meta-analyses have
confirmed its effectiveness for
postoperative pain, osteoarthritis, and
chronic musculoskeletal pain.
Conversely, results from the Bone and Joint
Decade 2000-2010 Task Force on Neck Pain,
reported in early 2008, showed no clinically
significant benefit to TENS for the
treatment of neck pain when compared to
placebo treatment. A
January 2010, systematic literature search
published in the journal Neurology,
advised against recommending TENS for
chronic low back pain since evidence is
controversial for that type of pain.
However, other neurologists wrote in the
same issue of the journal: "Absence of
evidence is not evidence of absence," and
although the research on TENS may be thin,
"there seems to be considerable empirical
evidence that, at least in some patients,
TENS is useful."
Recent clinical studies and meta-analysis
suggest that having an adequate intensity of
stimulation is necessary to achieve pain
relief with TENS.
Scientific studies show that high and low
frequency TENS produce their effects by
activation of opioid receptors in the
central nervous system. Specifically, high
frequency TENS activates delta-opioid
receptors both in the spinal cord and
supraspinally (in the medulla) while low
frequency TENS activates beta-opioid
receptors both in the spinal cord and
supraspinally. Further high frequency TENS
reduces excitation of central neurons
that transmit nociceptive information,
reduces release of excitatory
neurotransmitters (glutamate) and increases
the release of inhibitory neurotransmitters
(GABA) in the spinal cord, and activates
muscarinic receptors centrally to produce
analgesia (in effect, temporarily blocking
the pain gate). Low frequency TENS also
releases serotonin and activates serotonin
receptors in the spinal cord, releases GABA,
and activates muscarinic receptors to reduce
excitability of nociceptive neurons in the
spinal cord.
In palliative care and
pain medicine, TENS units are used in an
attempt to temporarily alleviate neuropathic
pain (pain due to
nerve damage). Some patients benefit from
this approach, while others do not,
depending on individual differences,
and pain threshold.
Use of TENS causes cell death at the site of
application and should not be used long
term. The number of cells that die is
insignificant and most patients heal without
complaints. TENS is more effective at
relieving chronic pain, whereas when used on
new injuries it sometimes aggravates the
pain. Further use is documented in the
attached references: in obstetric care,
particularly in labour;
knee pain; lithotripsy
or bladder-stone removal;
and limb pain.
A significant number of
TENS machine brands have been targeted for
use for labour pain, although a 1997 report
of a study done by the University of Oxford
said that TENS "has been shown not to be
effective in postoperative and labour pain."
TENS electrodes should
never be placed:
- Over the eyes due to
the risk of increasing intraocular
pressure.
- Tran cerebrally
- On the front of the
neck due to the risk of a acute
hypotension (through a vasovagal reflex)
or even a laryngospasm.
- Through the chest
using an anterior and posterior
electrode positions,
or other transthoracic applications
understood as "across a thoracic
diameter"; this does not preclude
coplanar applications
- Internally, except
for specific applications of dental,
vaginal, and anal stimulation that
employ specialized TENS units
- On broken skin areas
or wounds, although it can be placed
around wounds.
- Over a
tumour/malignancy (based on in vitro
experiments where electricity promotes
cell growth)
- Directly over the
spinal column
TENS should not be used
across an artificial cardiac pacemaker (or
other indwelling stimulator, including
across its leads) due to risk of
interference and failure of the implanted
device. Serious accidents have been recorded
in cases when this principle was not
observed.
A 2009 review in this
area suggests that electrotherapy, including
TENS, "are best avoided" in patients with
pacemakers or implantable
cardioverter-defibrillators (ICDs). They add
that "there is no consensus and it may be
possible to safely deliver these modalities
in a proper setting with device and patient
monitoring", and recommend further research.
The review found several reports of ICDs
administering inappropriate treatment due to
interference with TENS devices, but notes
that the reports on pacemakers are mixed:
some non-programmable pacemakers were
inhibited by TENS, but others were
unaffected or auto-reprogrammed.
On areas of numb
skin/decreased sensation TENS should be used
with caution because it's likely less
effective due to nerve damage. It may also
cause skin irritation due to the inability
to feel currents until they are too high.
There's an unknown level of risk when
placing electrodes over an infection
(possible spreading due to muscle
contractions), but cross contamination with
the electrodes themselves is of greater
concern. TENS should
also be used with caution in people with
epilepsy or pregnant women; do not use over
area of the uterus as the effects of
electrical stimulation over the developing
foetus are not known.